Pool Deck Refinish vs. Resurface: What’s the Difference?
When it comes to restoring or upgrading your pool deck, two terms often come up: refinishing and resurfacing. While they are sometimes used interchangeably, refinishing and resurfacing are actually distinct processes, each offering different benefits depending on the condition of your pool deck and the results you’re hoping to achieve.
Both refinishing and resurfacing are excellent ways to improve the appearance, safety, and durability of your pool area, but understanding the difference between the two can help you make a more informed decision about which option is right for your home.
In this article, we’ll break down the key differences between pool deck refinish and resurfacing, explaining what each process involves, when each is appropriate, and what benefits they offer. By the end, you’ll have a clearer idea of which option will best suit your pool deck needs.
What is Pool Deck Refinishing?
Pool deck refinish refers to the process of restoring or renewing the appearance of your existing pool deck by applying a protective coating or top layer. This process typically involves cleaning, repairing any surface imperfections (such as minor cracks or stains), and applying a new layer of material or finish over the old one. Refinishing is generally a cosmetic upgrade rather than a structural fix.
Common Refinishing Options:
Concrete Staining or Painting: Adds color and freshens up the deck’s appearance with paint or stain.
Seal Coating: A thin layer of protective sealant is applied to protect the surface from stains, weather, and wear.
Epoxy or Acrylic Coatings: These coatings provide an extra layer of durability and often have an aesthetic component as well (like adding a shiny finish or color).
Rubberized Coating: Provides a cushioned, slip-resistant surface and is available in different colors.
When to Consider Refinishing:
Cosmetic Enhancement: If your pool deck is structurally sound but has become worn, faded, or stained, refinishing can revitalize its appearance.
Minor Damage: If your pool deck has light cosmetic damage, like small cracks, chips, or fading, refinishing can help restore the surface without the need for major repairs.
Protective Coating: Refinishing often includes applying a protective layer that helps reduce further wear and tear, UV damage, and staining caused by pool chemicals, water, or foot traffic.
Benefits of Pool Deck Refinishing:
Cost-Effective: Refinishing is often more affordable than resurfacing or replacing a pool deck entirely.
Quick Turnaround: The refinishing process is typically faster than resurfacing. Most refinishing projects can be completed in just a few days.
Improves Appearance: It’s a great option for giving your pool deck a refreshed look with color, gloss, or texture.
Adds Protection: Refinishing with the right coatings or sealants provides a layer of protection against future wear and weathering.
Minimal Disruption: Refinishing doesn’t involve a full reconstruction of the pool deck, meaning less disruption to your outdoor space.
What is Pool Deck Resurfacing?
Pool deck resurfacing is a more extensive process that involves applying a completely new layer of material over the existing deck to restore or improve both the appearance and functionality of the surface. Resurfacing is typically used for pool decks with more significant damage, such as large cracks, uneven surfaces, or deep stains that cannot be repaired with refinishing alone.
Common Resurfacing Options:
Concrete Overlays: A thin layer of new concrete is applied over the old surface to provide a fresh, smooth finish. This is commonly done with decorative overlays, such as stamped concrete or textured coatings.
Stamped Concrete: This involves adding a new layer of concrete and stamping it with patterns that resemble natural stone, tile, or brick.
Pebble Tec or Exposed Aggregate: This method involves applying a mixture of small pebbles and concrete for a more textured, decorative look.
Cool Decking: A popular option in warmer climates, cool decking reduces the surface temperature of the pool deck, making it more comfortable to walk on during hot days.
When to Consider Resurfacing:
Extensive Damage: If your pool deck has larger cracks, large patches of discoloration, or is uneven, resurfacing is often the better choice. Resurfacing can cover up these imperfections and restore structural integrity to the surface.
Major Cosmetic Issues: If your pool deck’s appearance has significantly deteriorated—whether due to fading, staining, or chipping—resurfacing can give it a completely new look.
Structural Concerns: If your pool deck has shifted or sunk in some areas, resurfacing can level the surface and address these problems.
Durability Concerns: If your pool deck is showing signs of wear and tear that refinishing won’t resolve, resurfacing is a more permanent solution for restoring the deck’s functionality.
Benefits of Pool Deck Resurfacing:
Covers Extensive Damage: Resurfacing is ideal for pool decks that have significant cracks, chips, or structural damage that refinishing can’t fix.
Longer-Lasting: A resurfaced deck is often more durable and can last many more years compared to just refinishing an existing deck.
Customization Options: Resurfacing offers a wider variety of design and texture options (such as stamped concrete, exposed aggregate, and decorative overlays) that can completely transform the look of your pool area.
Increases Safety: If your pool deck is uneven, cracked, or slippery, resurfacing can correct these issues, making the surface smoother, safer, and more slip-resistant.
Better Protection: Resurfacing materials are often thicker and more durable than refinishing coatings, providing a stronger barrier against the elements and wear over time.
Refinishing vs. Resurfacing: Key Differences
Feature | Refinishing | Resurfacing |
Extent of Work | Generally a surface-level enhancement. | A more extensive process involving a new layer or overlay. |
Purpose | Primarily cosmetic, to restore the appearance and protect the deck. | Fixes both aesthetic and structural issues; can repair cracks and uneven surfaces. |
Cost | More affordable; and typically less expensive than resurfacing. | More expensive due to the materials and labor involved. |
Time | Faster process; can usually be completed in a few days. | Takes longer, especially for larger areas or complex designs. |
Damage Addressed | Best for minor wear, fading, and small cracks. | Ideal for large cracks, uneven surfaces, or extensive damage. |
Durability | Provides protection but may not address deeper structural issues. | More durable, as it adds a completely new layer with higher resistance. |
Customization | Limited to the finishes or coatings applied. | Highly customizable, with options for decorative patterns, textures, and finishes. |
Which Option Is Right for You?
The choice between pool deck refinish and resurfacing depends on the condition of your pool deck and the results you're hoping to achieve:
Choose Pool Deck Refinishing if:
Your deck is structurally sound, but it has cosmetic issues like fading discoloration, or light surface damage.
You’re looking for a quick, cost-effective way to improve the appearance of your deck.
You want to add a protective coating to prolong the life of your deck.
Choose Pool Deck Resurfacing if:
Your pool deck has major cracks, uneven surfaces, or other structural issues that refinishing won’t address.
You’re seeking a complete overhaul of your pool deck’s appearance.
You want to improve the deck’s durability and safety over the long term.
Conclusion
Both pool deck refinishing and resurfacing offer ways to enhance the look, safety, and longevity of your pool area, but the right choice depends on the condition of your deck and your specific needs. Refinishing is a great option for cosmetic upgrades and minor repairs, while resurfacing is the go-to solution for more significant damage or a complete makeover.
If you’re unsure which option is best for your pool deck, it’s always a good idea to consult with a professional contractor who can assess the condition of your deck and recommend the most suitable solution. Whether you choose to refinish or resurface your pool deck, both options will enhance your outdoor space, making it a more attractive and functional area for relaxation and entertainment.
Reference: Concrete swimming pool deck
Reference: Pool deck refinishing